This article first appeared in the Spring 2005 issue of the Edina Historical Society newsletter. I thought of it again after my seven-year search for the Santrizos of the Convention Grill came to fruition. Here's the back story on how this journey began.

I’m no Indiana Jones. I don’t travel the world, swing over pits of poisonous snakes, and machete my way through a jungle to find ancient artifacts. But nonetheless, I am a treasure hunter.

Sure, many times people just walk in our door and give us great things. But sometimes, we have to hunt down things we want. Okay, so I’m never in any danger… I just search the Internet or the Edina directory, pick up the phone and simply ask (or sometimes gently nag) to get treasures for our collection.
Picture
To get items for our (2005) Morningside exhibit, we sent out flyers to the Morningside neighborhood, made personal pleas at Edina-Morningside Women’s Club meetings sent emails, and called dozens of people.

In response, we got several photos, Boy Scout and Edina-Morningside Church items (on loan), a Morningside phone book, papers from the re-annexation vote, and Constable George Weber’s handgun. (That's George with the gun in the photo at left. Yes, I know the quality of the photo is horrible. I scanned it from an creased newspaper clipping, undated and unnamed, but I'm guessing the source is the Minneapolis Tribune.)

While it seems un-Minnesotan to be so forthright, I also ask exhibit visitors to add to our collection.

As a result, Susan Linhoff Peck  (whose parents started Linhoff Photo in Morningside) brought in a 1914 Morningside color map she found at a St. Cloud auction, and Betty Helmerichs O’Neil donated her 1939 Morningside Girl Scout uniform. Wendy Anderson sent us the mayoral badge and a photo of her grandfather Oscar Seidemann, former mayor of Morningside who “never left the house without his hat.”

We knew we wanted more information and photos about the Morningside businesses, so we tried to find the original owners. Finding women is especially difficult because their names change with marriage; some names like Carlson are just too common to be useful.

EHS volunteer Martha Johnson went to school with Marilyn Carlson, whose mother ran Carlson’s Odd Shop on Sunnyside and France Avenue. After some digging Martha found her, back in Edina after living in other states for several years. Marilyn was happy to share her photos with us.

I also wanted childhood photos of Curt Carlson, (not related to the Carlsons of Carlson’s Odd Shop) one of Minnesota’s wealthiest men who started his business career as a Morningside paper boy. I called Carlson Companies and was promised a call back. When I didn’t hear anything, Martha contacted the Carlson family, her former neighbors in the Country Club neighborhood. We got a photo of Curt and neighborhood friends at one of his birthday parties (see below), as well as his parent’s wedding photo.

Carlson’s parents ran a Morningside grocery store that they later sold to Lars Belleson. (Belleson's grocery is now the new co-op, but you might know the name from the 50th and France men's clothing store founded by son Wes Belleson.)

And yes, sometimes great stuff just walks in the door. One man asked why we didn’t have any photos of Joyce’s Bakery. When I said we were looking for the former owners, he said, “Well, that’s me.” Stan Rice bought the bakery from the Joyce family in the 1950s, and kept the name because of its fame in South Minneapolis and Edina. He turned out the same great breads and little cherry pies as his predecessor. He’s going to sort through his business stuff and return with items for our collection.

Flash forward to today:  I spoke (wrote) too soon regarding Joyce's Bakery. Stan did not return with photos and it should come to no surprise to you after reading this post that I didn't leave it at that. I called him and found he had been having health issues. Understandably, looking through old business files didn't fall at the top of his list but he planned to get to it when he felt better. After some time, I called his number again and found it disconnected.  I've called a few Rice families since then, all very nice, but not related to the Joyce's Bakery owner. The search continues.....

You might notice that the 2005 story didn't mention the Santrizos or the Convention Grill. At that point, we had some photos of the Convention in our collection  so I wasn't looking for more necessarily. It wasn't until people talked so warmly about the former owners that I started my search for the photos of Pete and Christine Santrizos that were published on the blog yesterday - seven years after my quest began.

You can help!
Join us in our treasure hunt. See our wish list below, or look through your own boxes of memorabilia for anything that tells Edina’s story. These are just a few of my many wants for the museum:
  • Edina neighborhood history. I would love to document every neighborhood in Edina as well as we have the Morningside neighborhood.
  • Morningside phone directories. We have a complete Edina phone directory collection, but we have only a couple from Morningside when it was a separate village from 1920 to 1966.
  • Photos by Edina professional photographers, including Don Berg, Dick Palen, Powell Krueger, and Dwight Miller. We would especially like any taken of Edina news events.
  • Southdale businesses over the years. And we'd love to know where the original bird cage went.  (See lower left in the 1963 postcard below.)
  • Other Edina businesses, whether they are retail shops at 50th and France, restaurants, or industry like the southwest area gravel pits and the dump.
  • Edina's history-making teams, such as the first girls' sports teams or our many state champions. I'd like to have all the state tournament programs, team photos, action photos, jerseys, etc.
For more information on donating, please email me or call me at the museum at 612-928-4577.
Bookmark and Share
 
 
Many of you remember Pete Santrizos, as he is pictured in the Edina Sun photo (dated Nov. 6, 1973) below. Pete held court behind the counter of the Sunnyside and France business and knew every customer, even if they had visited only once before. "His memory is terrific," reporter Debbie Pint wrote. "When someone walks in, he can usually recall their name, who they married, what they're doing."
The photo was taken after Pete had run the business for 32 years, taking over the struggling new restaurant on Nov. 1, 1941. At that point, he had no plans of closing, but his customers urged the local newspaper to write about the grandfatherly man who dispensed wisdom behind the counter as well as juicy hamburgers.

See the menu boards on the wall behind Pete? Here's one for those famous burgers ("hamburger steak") saved by the family:
Pete pointed out that in all the years that he ran the Convention, the only thing that changed were the prices. Even now, while the ownership has changed, the Convention's decor has changed little from when Pete bought the Convention in 1941 with a $200 loan from a relative.

Here Pete is pictured about the same time he bought the Morningside restaurant.
Pete came a long way from a lonely 15-year-old boy immigrating to the United States without his family in 1911. He started in the restaurant business washing dishes and sent money back home to his parents in Greece.

His wife Christine (below) was his life partner as well as his business partner, who worked in the kitchen creating nine homemade soups and was famous for her "Christine salad."  They lived in southwest Minneapolis, just seven blocks away from the Convention. Pete walked to work every day before 8 a.m. and returned home after 10 p.m. The Convention wasn't just their home away from home; it was home, where they spent nearly all of their waking hours with their three boys: Nicholas, Harry and Mario.

A 1942 photograph (below) in the family photo album shows the boys standing on Sunnyside Road with the Convention in the back ground. (You can also see the partial sign for the Westgate Dairy Store, which shared space in the building with the Convention. The dairy store, which was better known as simply Dennison's, later moved to the small building west of the parking lot. But that's another story for another day.)
"We never felt like we were working for our customers... they were our friends," Christine told Edina Sun reporter Jane Sims Podesta when the Santrizos retired in August 1976 after 35 years in the business.

Aren't these the greatest photos? I especially love the last one, with the distinct exterior of the Convention in the background. I have searched for photos of the much beloved Pete and Christine Santrizos ever since we created an exhibit about the Morningside neighborhood in 2005. Finally, seven years later, I have connected with the family, who graciously allowed us to copy photos from their albums.

I have a long wish list of photos and artifacts for our collection. Since we're on the topic of Morningside businesses, we have successfully hunted down photos of Burr Cheever's barber shop and Carlson's Odd Shop. I still want photos of the interior and owners of Morningside Hardware and Joyce's Bakery, among others.

If you know these owners or their families (or know someone who knows somebody who does), please contact me. Also, please share your memories of the Convention Grill and Pete and Christine by commenting here.

If you missed last Friday's post, check out the 1941 Convention ad here as well as two other Convention Grill posts here.

Bookmark and Share
 
 
One of our researchers found this ad for the Convention Grill (known then as just the Convention) in a 1941 issue of the Town Crier, a monthly magazine for the Country Club neighborhood.

I love the photo of the Morningside diner (3912 Sunnyside Avenue), but the text is truly priceless. For those who might have difficulty reading it from the image, here it is:

Just as the name implies, the CONVENTION is the gathering place of residents of Metropolitan Edina.

Men have found it particularly convenient in their rush for those important early morning appointments to forget about disturbing the whole household, and enjoy a real "He Man's Breakfast", and be on their way.

Here's just a suggestion that will make a hit with your husband, ladies; on maid's night out, make a date to meet him at the CONVENTION for dinner, then get the youngsters together, and walk over, it will sharpen the appetite of the whole family and save you a lot of fuss.

If you're in line for a real tasty snack, after the theatre or card party,  make a stop at the CONVENTION, we know there will be something on the menu to satisfy the hunger of everyone in the party.

Yes, truly the CONVENTION fills the bill for Edina families who enjoy the best in good eating. On each return visit to the CONVENTION Restaurant, you'll find more and more of your friends and neighbors, enjoying the comfortable, cozy, informality of the CONVENTION'S surroundings.

I can't decide what phrase makes me smile more: "He Man's Breakfast," or "maid's night out." The latter does bring to mind the old joke: Q. What does an Edina housewife make for dinner? A. Reservations. I know I'll be cooking tonight, but maybe we'll go to the Convention Grill (excuse me, CONVENTION) on "mom's night out" this weekend.

Happy Friday, everyone!
  • For more on the Convention Grill, see two previous blog posts here.
  • I have connected with the family of the original owners, Pete and Christine Santrizos, and will post photos of the family next week.
Bookmark and Share
 
 
Picture
Does this poster look familiar to you?

If you lived in Edina during the mid-1970s, it should. After all, the Harold and Maude movie poster hung in the Westgate Theater window for more than two years, from mid-1972 to June 1974. Yes, that's a record-breaking 1,957 showings. (For more on that and the Sunnyside and France movie theater in Morningside, see our previous post here.)

Steven Johnson worked at the theater and got the poster when the movie finally closed. The poster shows some age, but as Steve pointed out it was in use for much longer than the average movie run. He speculated that the poster may have first been on display at the Suburban World theater in Minneapolis when the movie opened in 1971.

This poster with simple text on a white background is the original poster. Later versions featured drawings or photos of stars Ruth Gordon and Bud Cort, who attended anniversary screenings at the Westgate. (Note that the movie rating predates the current system; instead of being rated PG, it's GP.)

Picture


Steve brought in the poster with his friend and fellow Harold and Maude fan Randy Greene, who helped organize the recent showing at the historic Heights Theater. Despite having seen the movie for many of those 1,957 showings as an employee, Steve still appreciates the cult classic.

Thanks you to both Steve and Randy for choosing the Edina Historical Society as a permanent home for the poster. They also brought in a group of newspaper clippings and ads that will be housed in our research files.

Do you have anything with an Edina connection that you think belongs in the Edina Historical Society collection? Please contact me for information about donating. We're a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization; the value of your donation may be tax deductible as allowed by law. The Society does not assign value.

A great majority of our items do not have a huge cash value, but they are priceless in terms of telling the history of our community. As I always say, we can't order Edina history from a catalog; our collection is a result of many years of donations from community-minded people.

Bookmark and Share
 
 
When the dark comedy “Harold and Maude” opened in mid-1972 at the Westgate Theater (4500 France Avenue), no one in the audience suspected that they would have another 1,956 opportunities to see the popular film that achieved a cult following.

For more than two years, “Harold and Maude” played at the Westgate – what seemed like a lifetime of missed Disney movies for a Morningside kid.

By the beginning of the third year, disgruntled neighborhood residents picketed the theater with signs reading,  “Our plea to Westgate. Your neighbors want variety” and “Two Years Too Much.”

Robert Owen was at the protest. "My mom and two of her neighbor friends organized it. She said the protestors consisted of the husbands and kids of the three women," he wrote, in answer to a query I posted on Facebook. "I remember booing at Ruth Gordon and the other actor when they showed up. My mom told me to stop that; the protest was not against the movie or actors but to get the theater to run some other films."

The Morningside record-breaking run of “Harold and Maude” brought it – and the movies’ stars Ruth Gordon and Bud Cort – national acclaim. Cort would say later that notice from the Minnesota run would boost his career.

In fact, both stars visited the Westgate Theater: Ruth Gordon attended the first anniversary showing, and both came for the second anniversary. (Picket signs protesting the movie’s long run can be seen in the background of one newspaper photo.)

In all, the movie played for a total of 1,957 showings from mid-1972 until June 1974 setting a new record for number of showings for any movies in the Twin Cities.

Another cult film, “The Rocky Horror Picture Show,” would break that record in the late 1970s, but the Westgate began the strategy of finding a market to stay alive in a time when multi-plex theaters took most of the movie business from small single-screen operations like Westgate.

"Harold and Maude" merely postponed the inevitable, and the Westgate finally closed in 1977. The building now houses Edina Dry Cleaners.

  • For more on the Westgate Theater's history, see this story from Edina Historical Society newsletter, Issue 3, 2010.
  • Count Edina native Jim Burke among the movie's fans. According to a recent story in the Star Tribune, the producer of the Academy Award nominated "The Descendants" spent many an afternoon at the Westgate Theater.  The story, written by Colin Colvert, says: Burke, 53, says he didn't plan it, but there is a sense of inevitability about his career. He grew up in a movie-theater family, ushering at his father's theater in the basement of the IDS building and tearing tickets at the old Yorktown Cinema. He displayed symptoms of film addiction early on. While at Edina High School he attended countless screenings of "Harold and Maude," which spent more than 100 consecutive weeks at his neighborhood Westgate Theater on the corner of 45th and France (presently the site of a laundromat). In 1982 he graduated from the University of Minnesota, moved to Los Angeles and landed a film-studio job because "I didn't realize I couldn't do it.
  • So, are you a lover or a hater of "Harold and Maude"? Were you among those kids who felt they missed out on years of children's movies? Did you carry protest signs? Or do you belong to the "Harold and Maude" cult following? Email me or comment here.
  • For more about the library housed in the theater and librarian Elvira Vinson, see this post

"Harold and Maude" showing to mark 40th anniversary of record run

Picture
If you didn't see "Harold and Maude" one of the more than 100 weeks it showed at the Westgate Theatre, now is your chance to see the movie cult classic on the big screen.

The Heights Theater in Columbia Heights will mark the 40th anniversary of Harold and Maude's historic run at the Morningside theater. Don't procrastinate: the movie will be showing only once on Wednesday, March 21 at 7:30 p.m.  Tickets are $8.

Go to see a cool restored movie house, even if you aren't a fan of the film. The theater opened in 1926 and is (according to its web site) "the Twin Cities' longest continuously operated show house."

See The Heights' web site for more information about the theater's history, location and movie schedule.

Bookmark and Share
 
 
Littel Street is a little street in the Morningside neighborhood of Edina. Although the street signs and current map read "Littel" (with the "EL" ending), a map dated 1905 is marked "Little" (with the "LE" ending.) Which is the typo?
I made the mistake of advocating for Little. The oldest map we have calls it Little. Hennepin County property tax records call it Little. What's more, it's a little street. Maybe subsequent mapmakers messed up and now we're calling that short street by the wrong name.

A Morningside volunteer argued just as strenuously for Littel. In fact, he went to the city many years ago when a new street sign showed up with "Little" on it and asked for a correction. (He got it.)

Turns out, he's probably right and I'm wrong. (That didn't hurt too much to admit.) The little street in Edina was probably named for Pauline Littel, a woman ahead of her time. In 1912, she was one of the few women working in real estate in Minneapolis and making a name for herself for more than just her gender. As the April 28, 1912, story in the Minneapolis Tribune put it, Littel was "often taken for the Office Girl, but She Puts Through Some Big Land Deals Just the Same."

Littel made news because "A $50,000 deal was closed in a real estate transaction one day last summer and a woman was responsible for it. It was Miss Pauline Little, who negotiated what has since been acknowledged as one of the largest deals in land made during the year."

In today's dollars, $50,000 would be more more than one million. The accomplishment had people wondering about the young single woman, and Pauline told the reporter that traffic had increased around her Lake Harriet office because "they just want to see what I look like."

The young and attractive Littel was often mistaken for the "office girl," but she said she won over her clients with confidence, knowledge of the business and honesty. "I know that absolute honesty in real estate transactions is the only sure route to success."

Littel also forged her own path from her male competitors and designed and built her own houses to sell, rather than only empty lots. All her homes sold within a month of their completion, and she credited her "daily work in the kitchen" for giving her the knowledge to design "sane spacing of cupboards, stove, sink and kitchen table."

In other words, Littel was designing work triangles for the kitchen, long before the term was coined in the 1940s.

Littel spent four years working in a real estate office before establishing her own business. She studied law books in her spare time to be prepared to handle real estate transactions. After a year, she began designing houses and overseeing construction.

Good design sells houses, she said. "Wide porches, light, well aired closets and cozy fireplace nooks all make the difference between a home that people want to buy and a rented house that they want to move out of at the first expiration of their lease."

I heard about Pauline Littel when I saw that local historian and architect Peter Sussman was giving a talk about her to the Linden Hills History Study Group. When I asked whether our street was named after her, Peter did a little digging in property records and found that she did, in fact, design some houses in the Morningside area.

He'll talk more about her work in a Morningside walking tour this summer (date TBA). If you would like to be notified when the date is set, please email me with "Morningside Walking Tour" in the subject line.

After her marriage to businessman and fellow realtor L. T. Sheets in 1917, Pauline Littel disappears from the headlines and no longer advertises. In 1919, she is mentioned in a tabloid style story when her husband is sued by a "beauty culturist" (beauty shop worker, I'm guessing) for $50,000 on the charges that Sheets urged her to divorce her husband and promised to marry her. Instead, he married Littel. The court ruled in favor of the woman, and Sheets was ordered to pay $7,500.

Pauline Littel made a name for herself in the real estate field. It's only fitting that a little piece of Edina's real estate bears her name.
Bookmark and Share
 
 
1. Jan Riesberg story prompted a couple of comments about the Morningside neighborhood. Jay Magoffin wrote: "Although I did not live in Morningside I have an attachment to the Community. Our family went to the Morningside Church. I was a Cub Scout their and my father was a Boy Scout leader. Many of my class mates lived in Morningside and because our class was so large we went to 5th grade in the new addition of the Morningside school." Kate Genovese commented on Facebook: "I grew up in Morningside! but, I was even north of 42nd... was just back there to visit my folks over Thanksgiving! it's a cute 'hood... changing, but still cute!"

Kate's comment prompted me to correct the border to read 40th Street. John Dudley also pointed out that Morningside was in the northeast corner, not northwest as I had written. I have to admit that directions are my downfall. Even when I know exactly where something is, I am directionally impaired when describing it. (This leads to some interesting detours when I ride shotgun and am in charge of the map, but that is another story....)

Nancy Olmem thought she might be able to find contact information for the Riesbergs. Thank you, Nancy!

2. Highway 100 beehives: John Dudley also commented on a post about Lilac Way (Highway 100), "The Beehive was moved to its final location at the South East corner of Hwy. 100 and Hwy. 7. Right beside the tall cement silo on the property of Nordic Ware. The silo was the very first one made of cement, architects from around the country all agreed - it would collapse because of the weight. It still stands today. Check out this website (St. Louis Park Historical Society) for more details."

Take John's advice and read more about the beehives and Highway 100 (aka Lilac Way). In fact, check out the entire site (see below)....

3. St. Louis Park Historical Society web site: I am a big fan of the St. Louis Park Historical Society web site and webmaster Jeanne Anderson, a volunteer board member who spends an amazing amount of time adding content to the site. (I often tell Jeanne that I want our site to be as complete as hers when "it grows up."Jeanne also wrote and continues to add to The Brookside Timeline web site about the neighborhood formed in 1907 around Brookside Avenue, which includes part of Edina. Check out both sites for great stories about our shared history, including Docken's store at 44th and Brookside, Park High School (attended by many Edina residents before our first high school was built in 1949), Bunny's bar (a favorite hangout of Edinans, who couldn't get liquor in their own town for many years) and much more.

Jeanne wrote about her memories about growing up on Highway 100 for our blog here, and has given me permission to use some of her material from time to time. I am happy that I am surrounded by so many great colleagues at the historical societies at our borders: Richfield Historical Society, Hopkins Historical Society, Linden Hills History Study Group, Eden Prairie Historical Society and the Bloomington Historical Society. Although we each focus on our particular communities, topics don't always fall neatly within city borders and we work together when possible.

4. CSI and Ralph's update: I wasn't the only one wondering about the CSI episode that mentioned Edina cake eaters. People searched for "csi edina" and "cake eater CSI" and other variations and landed on our site, making it our top blog post for the month of December.  For those who missed the outcome of the Ralph's Shoe Repair story, see the Star Tribune story and the Sun newspaper story on its move from Southdale mall to Richfield.

Happy Monday, everyone!


_
Bookmark and Share
 
 
People who complain about "big government" probably never heard of the tiny Village of Morningside, which operated with two employees, no village hall and a few contracted services from its larger neighbor, the Village of Edina.

Morningside, the far northwest corner of present day Edina, needed little government as the smallest village in Hennepin County. Its borders extended just a few blocks in either direction: approximately 42nd Street and Sunnyside Avenue at the north and south, and France Avenue and Oakdale Avenue to the east and west.

Council meetings were held at the Odd Fellows Hall at the northwest corner of 44th and France, but otherwise, village business was conducted from the basement of Village Clerk Janet Riesberg's at 4003 Lynn Avenue.

From her informal home office, Riesberg typed council minutes, sold dog licenses and even registered candidates for elections sometimes minutes before midnight, the deadline for filing. A widow with three daughters, she was happy to be a “work-at-home” mother. Her children were trained in to answer the phone and assist residents.

Some Morningsiders viewed Janet’s marriage to Edina City Manager Warren Hyde as prophetic – not long after the couple’s wedding, Morningside voted to rejoin Edina in 1966 after 46 years of independence.

The other employee, Harold Schwartz, conducted his city business from a snow plow or truck. The lone Public Works employee took care of the city's ice rink at Weber park, plowed streets, and repaired roads. (Well known police officer George Weber had retired by this time. He quit patrolling for speeders in 1954 at approximately 80 years old, after 28 years on the job.)

Former neighbors of the Riesbergs visited the Edina History Museum today to see the current "Growing Up in Edina" exhibit. As we talked about the days of the tiny village, I recalled this article in our collection. If you know where the Riesberg daughters are today, the former neighbor girls would love to talk to them. Please email me if you have contact information.
Bookmark and Share
 
 
Do you remember the kids who were in your kindergarten class? Today, most school photos are done by companies that specialize in school portrait photography and the class photo is printed with every child's name. Heck, even elementary schools have yearbooks these days. But in 1948, class photos were not that fancy: just line the kids up against a classroom wall, try to get them to look at the camera and hope they keep their eyes open and their fingers out of their mouths.

Bonnie Ott England submitted this photo of her 1948-49 Morningside kindergarten class for our "Growing Up in Edina" exhibit -- that opens on Oct. 29 -- along with her nap-time blanket. This was a time when children weren't expected to know their colors, numbers and letters before they walked in the door. They went to school just a couple of hours a day, and part of the day's activities included a nap. (Makes you want to go to kindergarten again, doesn't it?)

She and her sister Sherry could come up with many of the names of her classmates. If you can help identify these youngsters, please comment here.

Left to Right:
Top row: (1) ?  (2) Kathy McKeon?  (3) ?  (4) ?  (5) ?  (6) Ann Fenger  (7) Mark Hanson
2nd row from top: (1) ?  (2) ?  (3) Nancy Hallberg  (4) ?  (5) ?  (6) Carolyn Tews  (7) Jacque Simpson  (8) Bonnie Ott  (9) ?
3rd row from top: (1) ?  (2) ?  (3) ?  (4) ?  (5) ?  (6) Sarah Hawthorne  (7) Rodney Brown
2nd row from bottom: (1) Carole Blandin? (2) ?  (3) ?  (4) Vicki Dahlberg  (5) ?  (6) ?  (7) Pat Kennedy?
Bottom row: (1) Danae Edwards  (2) ?  (3) ?  (4) ?  (5) Marilyn Holtze?  (6) ?  (7) ?  (8) Jane Parker

We have several class photos in our collection; volunteers are working on putting some on poster board for exhibit visitors to view as part of the exhibit. Thanks to retired teacher Bernice Amacher, we also have several faculty group photos from Cornelia and Cahill Schools. At this point, most have only the school and year identified. We'd like to ID the people in the photos with visitors' help.
Bookmark and Share
 
 
This article originally ran in a Fall 2004 Edina Historical Society newsletter. We're dusting off the story in honor of apple season and to dispel a few myths still circulating about Edina's contribution to the apple world.
Picture
Jonathan T. Grimes
What apple did Edina pioneer Jonathan Grimes develop?
A. Jonathan
B. Grimes
C. Jonagold
D. A and C
E. None of the above

 Although a local newspaper once quoted Grimes descendants as crediting Jonathan Grimes as the developer of the Jonathan apple, horticultural sources say otherwise.

“I think that’s some family folklore that just isn’t correct,” said Grimes' great-grandson Boyd Phelps. The claim is not substantiated by any source, including Jonathan Grimes’ daughter Ella Grimes Eustis, who wrote a memoir Out of My Mind.

“My grandmother was a stickler for detail, and she never mentioned the Jonathan apple,” Phelps said.


The fact that Jonathan Grimes shares the name of the above apple breeds is a confusing coincidence, especially since Grimes was a prominent Minnesota horticulturalist and apple grower. From 1866 to 1883, he owned the Lake Calhoun Nursery, (later subdivided into the Morningside neighborhood.)

Hardy trees
Although Grimes did grow apple trees, he achieved his greater fame developing shade trees hardy enough to withstand Minnesota winters.

As his daughter writes, “My father’s evergreens and shade trees were sold and planted in many parts of Hennepin County. The large shade trees that adorned Nicollet, Hennepin, Lyndale and University Avenues came from his nursery.”

Grimes imported some exotic – for the times – tree varieties, including the ginkgo tree from China. “Only one of these trees survived,” Eustis writes. “… (The tree) was only a few blocks from Central High School, and for many years the botany classes came to study it. It grew about fifty feet high... Now ginkgo trees may be found in nurseries but they are scarce.”

If Jonathan Grimes did indeed create any new apple variety, Ella Grimes Eustis had the perfect opportunity to mention his accomplishment when she writes of Peter Gideon, a fellow horticulturalist who bred the Wealthy apple.

But she mentions only Gideon’s well-known eccentricities.

Peter Gideon and the Wealthy apple
“In connection with his nursery and his experiments with new and hybrid shrubs, trees, etc., my father became acquainted with Peter M. Gideon, later the originator of the Wealthy apple. He lived on the west side of Gideon’s Bay, Lake Minnetonka, where he had his orchard. With horse-drawn vehicle it was a long, slow trip to Minneapolis from his home, so he planned his trips very nicely by arriving at our house always just before supper and staying overnight with breakfast included.

“Mr. Gideon was a great talker and bragger, and a strong spiritualist. Mother took his all too frequent visits in her stride, but, having been brought up in a strictly orthodox faith, she did not relish his enthusiastic harangues on spiritualism – especially with children of impressionable ages sitting around with their ears wide open. The last straw came when he claimed he could cure anybody or anything by laying his hands on the individual and calling up on the Spirits. Father had had a prolonged case of rheumatism, so at the height of this emotional discourse my mother said, ‘Mr. Gideon, if you can cure anybody, I wish you could cure Mr. Grimes of his rheumatism.’ This came as a surprise, and Mr. Gideon’s reaction was terrific. He jumped up and down in a combination of excitement, hysteria, anger, and apparent insult; and uttering a tirade of unprintable words, he flew out the door and down the road. Mr. Gideon never returned – but the rheumatism never returned either….

“Mr. Gideon had to find another free lodging to take the place of ours. He selected the Hankes’ on the Excelsior road. As it was late and dark when he knocked on their door, Mr. Hanke opened a window to ask who was there. The answer came. ‘I’m Gideon.’ ‘Who?’ ‘Gideon!’ Whether or not Mr. Hanke wanted to understand I do not know, but his reply was, ‘No, you don’t gid in.’ ‘Don’t you understand – I’m Gideon!’ whereupon Mr. Hanke (a German) said in his broken English, ‘You tank you gid in, but you no gid in!’ And down went the window. Where Gideon went from there, we never knew.”

Despite their disagreements, Jonathan Grimes praised Gideon in his eulogy to colleagues of the Minnesota State Historical Society , saying Gideon would be “known by his fruits” and his perseverance in creating a hardy Minnesota apple, the Wealthy. “…This tree alone would stand as a monument to his memory.”
Picture
Minneapolis Tribune, March 25, 1885
Addendum: "An Orange Social"
As for Jonathan's daughter Ella, she was more intrigued by a strange new fruit: the orange. In 1876, she attended an "Orange Social," a gathering of more than 200 people who saw an expert demonstrate how to peel the exotic citrus.

She was not alone in her fascination: the Minneapolis Tribune reported on several such functions during this period.

For more information on Peter Gideon, see MNopedia website created by the Minnesota Historical Society.

Bookmark and Share